to get a room full of sexologists all riled up, ask them whether or not sex and porn can be classified as addictions. this debate has been going on for roughly four decades at this point, with seemingly no end in sight. what seems cut-and-dry at first glance actually requires careful consideration. if it walks like an addiction and talks like an addiction, can’t we just call it an addiction? while that is one model for understanding human behaviour, dr. prause, a neuroscientist who researches both human sexuality and addiction states, “i was never clear on why people started with the highest, most restrictive model in existence” to explain people’s problematic relationships with sex and porn (2025, 16:16). scientifically, it’s a high bar to meet the clinical markers for addiction, and the data on sex and porn fail repeatedly (prause, 2025). yet, if they are not accurately classified as addictions, how do we frame the issue?
many people find the addiction label to be apt for describing porn use or sexual behaviours that feel out of one’s control. while it’s true that there can be devastating impacts from the sexual choices that people make, professionally speaking, language matters. the way we frame an issue determines how we approach it. the question is not whether problematic sexual behaviour exists: it clearly does. rather, the question is whether addiction is the most accurate clinical framework for understanding it.
what’s the cost of missing a diagnosis by labelling something an addiction without investigating more carefully? what are the fallouts of creating medical diagnoses for behaviours that are better understood within their cultural, moral, or social contexts? psychiatry has wrestled with these questions before. homosexuality was a diagnosable condition until it was removed from the dsm, and there are many similar examples to show that collectively, what we sanction or condemn changes. accurately understanding the clinical and, at times, social issues is key to how we shape our support as counsellors.
this can be a hard topic on which to thread the needle well. the current best research does not endorse addiction as an accurate model for describing problematic sexual behaviour. however, as clinical psychologist and sex researcher dr. staley points out, “not finding support for sex addiction and disproving sex addiction are two very different things” (2019, 7:10). we must take our time and consider the research carefully.
where we’ve been
a review of how we’ve historically understood problematic sexual behaviour reminds us that many psychiatric diagnoses are shaped by the culture in which they emerge. the first edition of the diagnostic and statistical manual (dsm) in 1952 mentioned nymphomania to describe women with “excessive” or “uncontrollable” sexual behaviour. this was removed from the dsm-ii, and added again in the dsm-iii, along with don juanism, describing men with a compulsive need for sexual conquest. both were removed from the dsm-iv, which included only a category of “sexual disorder, not otherwise specified” to describe sexual excess or dysregulation (braun-harvey & vigorito, 2016). a hypersexuality diagnosis was considered for the dsm-v, but ultimately excluded due to lack of empirical support (braun-harvey & vigorito, 2016; frances, 2013).
against the backdrop of these developments was the work of dr. carnes, a counsellor and educator who developed a model of sex and porn addiction in his 1983 book, out of the shadows: understanding sexual addiction. this framework has influenced our cultural understanding of how we view problematic sexual behaviour. however, the addiction model emerged more than forty years ago, and both addiction science and human sexuality research have advanced considerably since then. many of today’s critiques centre on whether that model continues to fit the available evidence, particularly given concerns about pathologizing sexual behaviours that may instead be better understood within their social contexts.
where we are today
in its most recent edition of the international classification of diseases, the world health organization includes a diagnosis of compulsive sexual behaviour disorder. classified as an impulse control disorder, it may be considered a middle ground of sorts between those who argue that problematic sexual behaviour is an addiction and those who do not. it acknowledges that there’s a problem without presuming that addiction is the correct explanatory model. moreover, it recognizes that some people do, indeed, feel out of control with their sexual behaviour and persist with it despite adverse consequences and clinically significant impairment. the disorder must cause marked distress or significant impairment; yet its criterion of distress emphasizes that if it is entirely related to “moral judgement, cultural values, or religious beliefs” it is insufficient to meet diagnostic requirements (world health organization, 2022, “compulsive sexual behaviour disorder (6c72)”). the dsm-v includes no such diagnostic equivalent.
the american association of sexuality educators, counselors, and therapists (aasect), a leading north american organization in establishing best practices and ethical guidelines for sexual health, publishes position statements when “contentious topics and cultural conflicts impede sexuality education and health care” (aasect, n.d.). aasect notes that there is insufficient empirical evidence to support sex and porn use as mental health disorders, and that addiction-based training, treatments, and pedagogies are inadequately informed by accurate human sexuality knowledge. consequently, “linking problems related to sexual urges, thoughts or behaviors to a porn/sexual addiction process cannot be advanced by aasect as a standard of practice for sexuality education delivery, counseling or therapy” (aasect, n.d.). while research on how to best classify problematic sexual behaviour is ongoing, there remains no consensus regarding its etiology (braun-harvey & vigorito, 2016).
why definitions matter
despite its cultural resonance, where does the addiction model fall short? ultimately, the debate is not about whether sexual behaviour can become problematic. it’s about whether problematic sexual behaviour demonstrates the defining features of addiction. two clinical markers of addiction deserve attention here: tolerance and withdrawal. in her research, dr. prause (2025) found that sexual arousal and pornography do not show the brain patterns characteristic of addiction. rather than developing a tolerance and needing more intense images to stimulate brain activity, participants who self-identified as having problematic porn use, more sexual partners, or more sexual experience, were actually more sensitive to less explicit sexual stimuli than the control group.
dr. staley (2019), a self-identified mormon researcher, wanted to provide neurological evidence that porn is addictive. he actually found the opposite, noting that the brain patterns of people who believed they were addicted to porn did not resemble those of people who are addicted to drugs. however, a self-perceived porn addiction led to increased viewing (staley, 2019). moreover, those “who are religious are more likely to perceive themselves as addicted even though they’re not viewing at high rates” (7:42).
current research on withdrawal in sex and porn use is neither consistent nor conclusive (fernandez, 2023; ley, 2012). unlike substance addictions, where withdrawal reflects the brain and body’s adaptation to a drug, available data does not support that stopping sex or pornography produces a recognizable withdrawal syndrome. although people may experience distress, cravings, or discomfort, these are neither specific to sexual behaviour nor indicative of physiological dependence (fernandez et al., 2023).
perhaps the greatest risk of adopting an addiction framework uncritically is that it can blur the distinction between feeling out of control and actually being out of control (ley, 2012). if we frame sexual behaviour as truly beyond a person’s control, it justifies (if not excuses) all manner of nonconsensual activity. as braun-harvey and vigorito assert, “one’s drive to have sex is not literally stronger than one’s ability to choose or direct behavior” (2016, p. 56). clients can learn to notice that distinction and gain competence in making choices that align with their values.
another key issue is how to distinguish normal from abnormal behaviour. dr. frances, a psychiatrist who served as chair of the american psychiatric association task force overseeing the development and revision of the dsm-iv, notes that the “lack of consensus on what is normal sexual behavior makes it difficult to define what is excessive” (2013, p. 143). how many times can one masturbate in a day? how many sexual partners can they have? is lying in the context of sexual behaviour a diagnosable condition? these questions can’t be answered by science alone; they exist within cultural contexts, whose norms are both varied and malleable. oftentimes, we can support clients in finding balance with their sexual expression without pathologizing their behaviour.
there’s no “mic drop” moment here for either camp. science works on theories, which ideally change when the research tells a different story. presently, available evidence points away from the addiction model for explaining sexual problems. however, moving away from one explanatory model does not automatically tell us how to replace it. it’s noteworthy that after four decades of research, there’s still no consensus on how to frame the issue diagnostically. what it does suggest is that problematic sexual behaviour is multifaceted. we know for sure that people who struggle with sexual behaviour often have diagnosable anxiety, depression, and/or substance use issues (ley, 2012; prause, 2025; staley, 2019). treating verifiable diagnoses, without adding ones that lack empirical support, is a prudent approach to working with sexual concerns (braun-harvey & vigorito, 2016; frances, 2013; ley, 2012; prause, 2025; staley, 2019).
regardless of where clinicians land in the debate, few would dispute that people can experience profound distress related to sexual behaviour; that relationships can be harmed; and that support is often warranted. the disagreement lies less in whether people suffer than in how we understand the source of that suffering. there are other ways to look at problematic sexual behaviour. for example, we can explore the quality of a person’s sexual health education, which can help clients distinguish facts from misinformation; reflect on their own values and sexual health goals; and challenge shame that may be shaping their experience (braun harvey & vigorito, 2016).
how does this help me in my practice?
it’s important for counsellors to feel comfortable talking about sexual matters. if we follow clients into their discomfort and fail to explore their experience more deeply, we miss developing a robust understanding of what feels problematic to them (braun-harvey & vigorito, 2016). fortunately, there are ways to develop such skills. for example, you can explore how you feel about discussing sexuality with clients using the comfort and willingness scale, which was developed for this purpose (the harvey institute, n.d.). you can seek continuing education in human sexuality, or find supervision to help you work with clients whose values or lifestyles differ from your own. if the work feels beyond your scope (e.g., nonconsensual sexual behaviour), knowing when to refer is a valuable skill to cultivate.
while there’s no one “best” treatment for working with problematic sexual behaviour, certain approaches are particularly useful. helping clients develop mindfulness through modalities like acceptance and commitment therapy allows them to notice sexual thoughts, urges, and emotions without being governed by them; explore potential ambivalence or contradictions without judgment; and ultimately choose behaviours that align more closely with their values (braun-harvey & vigorito, 2016; prause, 2025; staley, 2019). dispelling myths and offering quality sexual health information empowers clients to make informed choices with accurate knowledge. we can also assist them in developing a personal vision of sexual health by exploring principles like consent, nonexploitation, honesty, and pleasure (braun-harvey & vigorito).
frameworks matter. they shape the questions we ask, the assumptions we make, and the support we offer. regardless of how we conceptualize problematic sexual behaviour, our duties as counsellors remain the same. we want to examine our own values to better understand how they intersect with those of our clients; foster therapeutic trust by offering accurate information and comprehensive care; and ultimately, we aim to approach clients with curiosity, humility, and a commitment to appreciating the unique context of their own lived experience.
references
aasect. (n.d.). aasect position on sex addiction. retrieved july 19, 2026, from https://www.aasect.org/position-sex-addiction
braun-harvey, d., & vigorito, m. a. (2016). treating out of control sexual behavior: rethinking sex addiction. springer publishing company.
fernandez, d. p., kuss, d. j., justice, l. v. et al. effects of a 7-day pornography abstinence period on withdrawal-related symptoms in regular pornography users: a randomized controlled study. arch sex behav 52, 1819–1840 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10508-022-02519-w
frances, a., md. (2013). saving normal: an insider’s revolt against out-of-control psychiatric diagnosis, dsm-5, big pharma, and the medicalization of ordinary life. harper collins.
ley, d. j. (2012). the myth of sex addiction. rowman and littlefield.
prause, n. (2025, july 15). the truth about porn (essential listen) (j. lehmiller, interviewer; episode 414). https://www.sexandpsychology.com/blog/podcast/episode-414-the-truth-about-porn-essential-listen/
staley, c. & tedx idaho state university. (2019, december 3). changing the narrative around the addiction story. youtube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mNGg5SMcyhI
the harvey institute. (n.d.). comfort and willingness scale. https://www.theharveyinstitute.com/assets/content/uploads/2015/08/comfort-and-willingness-scale.pdf
world health organization. (2022). compulsive sexual behaviour disorder (6c72). in international classification of diseases for mortality and morbidity statistics (11th revision). https://icd.who.int/browse/2022-02/mms/en#/http://id.who.int/icd/entity/1630268048

0 comments